Last Updated on August 9, 2023 by Linda Richard
Training large dogs can be challenging, especially when managing their behavior and ensuring their safety.
While there are various training methods available, some pet owners opt for dog shock collars as a tool to modify their dog’s behavior.
It’s essential to choose the right shock collars that prioritize your dog’s well-being and provide effective training.
In this article, we will explore the key factors to consider when selecting the best dog shock collars.
| Image | Product | Features |
 | SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS Add-A-Dog Collar | Item dimensions: 9 x 5 x 7 in Weight: 0.7 lbs Closure type: Buckle |
 | PetSafe Remote Training Collar | Item dimensions: 2.67 x 1.05 x 1.38 in Weight: 3.84 oz Material: Nylon Batteries: 1 CR123A Battery life: up to a 40-hour |
 | SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers | Item display dimensions: 3.2 x 9.5 in Closure type: Button Item dimensions: 3.2 x 6.9 x 9.4 in Weight: 1.2 lbs Batteries: 1 Lithium-ion |
 | Remote Dog Training Collar | Closure type: Button Material: TPU strap – waterproof properties Item dimensions: 3.2 x 6.9 x 9.4 in Weight: 1.2 lbs Batteries: 1 Lithium-ion |
| SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425X Remote Trainers | Material: Plastic Closure type: Buckle Item dimensions: 2.6 x 1.2 x 1.3 in Weight: 1.76 oz Batteries: 2 Lithium-ion Battery life: 50-70 hours per charge |
 | Educator E-Collar Humane Dog Training Collar | Material: Biothane collar strap Item display dimensions: 1.1 x 4.5 in Item dimensions: 11.75 x 7.38 x 1.9 in Weight: 7.68 oz Batteries: 2 Lithium-ion |
 | SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS Stubborn Dog Remote Trainer | Closure type: Snap Item Dimensions: 2.6 x 1.2 x 1.3 in Weight: 1.76 oz Batteries: 2 Lithium-ion Battery life: 50-70 hours per charge |
 | PATPET Shock Collars | Item dimensions: 10.28 x 9.49 x 3.82 in Weight: 2.58 lbs Material: Thermoplastic polyurethane Breed recommendation: Medium breeds Batteries: 2 Lithium-ion |
Table of Contents
SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS Add-A-Dog Collar
The SportDOG 425XS is a waterproof and rechargeable dog shock collar, an additional or replacement dog shock collar for the SportDOG remote trainer system.
It provides a variety of training options, such as tone, vibration, and customizable levels of static stimulation.
This dog shock collar is specifically designed for most modern shock collars for large dogs and provides robust correction options.
Pros
- The durability and resilience of SportDOG products make them widely acknowledged for their capability to endure outdoor activities and rough handling.
- With its impressive range of capabilities, the product enables practical training and effective control over extended distances.
- Many units can be expanded to accommodate multiple dogs with the addition of extra dog collars, making them suitable for multi-dog households or professional use.
- The products offer versatility by providing three training modes and adjustable stimulation levels, allowing them to adapt to various training scenarios and accommodate different dog temperaments.
Cons
- Certain individuals and trainers may express reservations regarding the use of static stimulus (shock) as a training method, as it may not align with specific training philosophies that prioritize positive reinforcement techniques.
- The operation and customization of units may require a learning curve, especially for first-time users or those unfamiliar with electronic training devices.
- The products are frequently positioned as high-end training solutions, which can result in a higher price point compared to entry-level or basic training shock collars.
PetSafe Remote Training Collar
The PetSafe remote dog training collar is a versatile tool for training medium and large dogs.
With a 300-yard range, it allows effective off-leash training.
The dog shock collar offers three modes: tone, vibration, and 15 levels of static stimulus.
It fits comfortably on medium to large dogs.
The handheld remote control provides convenient and easy control over your dog’s training.
Pros
- The dog shock collar offers a choice between tone, vibration, and 15 levels of static stimulus, allowing for customization based on your dog’s training needs and sensitivities.
- With a range of 300 yards (900 feet), the dog shock collar provides sufficient distance for off-leash training and control, giving you flexibility during training sessions.
- The dog shock collar is designed to fit medium or large dogs, ensuring a comfortable and secure fit for your pet during training.
- The handheld remote control allows you to deliver commands and corrections to your dog from a distance, providing convenience and control during training sessions.
Cons
- The use of static stimulation as a training method may not be suitable for all dogs or training philosophies. It is important to use this feature responsibly and with proper guidance to ensure your dog’s well-being.
- Operating the remote control and understanding the collar’s functions may require a learning curve, particularly for first-time users or those unfamiliar with remote training devices.
- It’s important to carefully monitor your dog’s attention response to the dog training collar and adjust the stimulation level accordingly to avoid excessive or unnecessary correction.
SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers
The SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers is a high-quality electronic collar for effective dog training.
With a range of up to 500 yards, it allows training from a distance.
The dog collar offers three workout modes: static stimulation, vibration, and tone.
It is fully waterproof for training in wet conditions, and both the training collar have rechargeable batteries.
The X-Series technology ensures enhanced performance and reliability.
The trainer is expandable for up to 3 dogs with most dog shock collars.
The handheld remote is user-friendly, and the collar is lightweight and comfortable for medium to large dogs.
Pros
- With multiple workout modes, the remote trainer offers versatility to cater to different training requirements and dog temperaments, allowing for effective training and behavior correction.
- The 500-yard range gives you the ability to train your dog at a distance, making it suitable for outdoor activities such as hiking, hunting dogs, or off-leash training in large spaces.
- The collar and remote are built to withstand rugged use and outdoor conditions, ensuring durability and longevity even in challenging environments.
- The rechargeable batteries eliminate the need for constant battery replacements, providing comfort and peace of mind during training sessions.
Cons
- Operating and understanding the features of the remote trainer may require some time and effort, especially for first-time users or those new to e-collar training.
- While the collar offers adjustable stimulation levels, it’s essential to monitor your dog’s neck response closely to ensure the stimulation is appropriate and not overly aversive.
Remote Dog Training Collar
The Remote Dog Training Collar is an advanced and versatile tool for effective dog training.
With a range of ¾ mile, it allows training from a significant distance.
The collar offers multiple workout modes: shock, vibration, anti-bark, and beep.
It features a built-in night light for enhanced visibility in low-light conditions.
The collar has a removable shock feature for customizable training and is waterproof for durability in various weather conditions.
The remote can train up to 3 dogs at the same time with additional dog shock collars.
Suitable for dogs weighing 15 lbs and above, it accommodates big shock collars for large dogs and medium-sized breeds.
Pros
- The collar offers multiple workout modes: shock, vibration, anti-bark, and beep. This versatility allows you to choose the most appropriate mode for your dog’s training needs and temperament.
- With a range of ¾ mile, the collar provides the capability to train your dog from a considerable distance. This is particularly useful for outdoor activities or off-leash training in spacious areas.
- The collar is designed to be waterproof, ensuring its durability and functionality in various weather conditions. You can confidently use it during water-related activities or in wet environments without worrying about damage.
- The collar can be expanded to train up to 3 shock collars for large dogs at the same time by purchasing additional dog shock collars (sold separately). This feature is convenient for dog owners of multiple dogs or professional trainers working with multiple animals.
- The collar offers a removable shock element, providing flexibility in the training method. You can choose to use the collar with or without the shock option, tailoring the training experience to your preferences and your dog’s needs.
Cons
- The use of the Remote Dog Training Collar requires responsible usage and proper training techniques. It is important to follow the manufacturer’s instructions and seek guidance from professional trainers to ensure the well-being and safety of your dog during training.
- The collar is specifically designed for dogs weighing 15 lbs and above, making it unsuitable for small breeds. It is important to choose a collar that is appropriate for your dog’s size and weight to ensure a comfortable and safe fit.
- While the shock mode can be effective in some training scenarios, it is important to use it with caution and under professional guidance. The intensity and duration of the shock should be carefully adjusted to avoid causing unnecessary discomfort or harm to the dog.
SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425X Remote Trainer
The SportDOG 425X Remote Trainer is a reliable and feature-rich training collar designed to assist in effective dog training.
It offers a few training modes, including shock, vibration, and tone, allowing customization based on your dog’s neck needs.
With a 500-yard range, it provides ample distance for training collars in various outdoor environments.
The collar’s receiver and remotes have rechargeable dog shock collar batteries, eliminating the need for disposable batteries.
They are also waterproof, ensuring durability in wet conditions.
The system is expandable for training collars up to 3 dogs simultaneously, and the remote has a user-friendly design.
The collar is lightweight and fits comfortably on medium to large dogs.
Pros
- The collar offers a few training modes: shock, vibration, and tone. This versatility allows you to choose the most appropriate mode for your dog’s training needs and temperament.
- With a range of 500 yards, the collar provides sufficient distance to train your dog in various outdoor environments. This range is especially useful for activities such as off-leash training or working in large open spaces.
- The collars and the handheld remote feature rechargeable batteries, eliminating the need for disposable batteries. This provides convenience and saves you money on ongoing battery replacements.
- The collar receiver and the remote are designed to be waterproof, ensuring their durability and functionality even in wet conditions. You can confidently use the collar during outdoor activities, including swimming or training in rainy weather.
- The SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425X is an expandable system that allows you to train up to 3 dogs simultaneously with the purchase of additional dog shock collars (sold separately). This feature is convenient for dog owners of multiple or professional trainers working with multiple animals.
Cons
- The shock mode, although adjustable, may not be suitable for all hunting dogs or training philosophies. It’s important to use the shock mode responsibly and under the guidance of professional trainers to ensure the well-being and safety of your dog.
- The collar is designed specifically for use with the SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425X system. It may not be compatible with other systems or brands, limiting its versatility if you have different training equipment.
- Some users may find that mastering the operation of the handheld remote and navigating through the different modes and settings takes time and practice. Familiarizing yourself with the user manual and seeking guidance can help overcome this learning curve.
Educator E-Collar Humane Dog Training Collar
The Educator E-Collar Humane dog training collars are a feature-packed training tool designed to assist in training your dog effectively and safely.
The collar offers 100 levels of safe stimulation, allowing you to customize the intensity to match your dog’s sensitivity and training needs.
This wide range of stimulation levels ensures that you can find the appropriate level for your dog without causing unnecessary discomfort.
In addition to the stimulation levels, this collar also features a tapping sensation mode.
This gentle tapping sensation can be used as an alternative to static stimulation, providing a non-invasive way to communicate with your dog during training.
The collar is equipped with a built-in night light, enhancing visibility in low-light conditions.
This feature is particularly useful during evening walks or training sessions when visibility is limited.
The collar is designed to be waterproof, allowing you to use it in various weather conditions and water-related activities without worrying about damage.
Its durability ensures long-lasting performance, even in rugged outdoor environments.
Both the collar and the remote control feature rechargeable batteries, eliminating the need for disposable batteries.
The included charging cable allows for convenient and eco-friendly charging.
Pros
- The collar offers a wide range of safe stimulation levels, allowing you to find the most appropriate level for your dog’s training needs without causing harm or discomfort.
- The tapping sensation mode provides an alternative to static stimulation, offering a gentler way to communicate with your dog during training sessions.
- The built-in night light enhances visibility in low-light conditions, ensuring safety and convenience during evening walks or training sessions.
- The collar is designed to be waterproof, making it suitable for use in various weather conditions and water-related activities. This feature adds durability and reliability to the collar.
- Both collars and the remote control are equipped with rechargeable batteries, eliminating the need for disposable batteries. This saves you money and ensures convenience during training sessions.
- The collar has a range of 1/2 mile, providing ample distance for effective communication and training in outdoor environments.
Cons
- Some users may find it challenging to navigate through the various settings and modes initially. Familiarizing yourself with the user manual and seeking guidance from professional trainers can help overcome this learning curve.
- This particular model is designed for training one dog only. If you have multiple dogs, you may need to purchase additional dog shock collars or consider a different model that supports training multiple dogs.
- While the stimulation levels are designed to be safe and adjustable, it’s important to monitor your dog’s response and sensitivity to ensure that the chosen level is appropriate for their comfort and well-being.
SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS Stubborn Dog Remote Trainer
The SportDOG 425XS shock collars for large dogs are a complete training system.
It provides effective training features to address challenging dog’s behavior and achieve consistent results.
With the additional dog shock collar, you can train two dogs at the same time, making it convenient for owners with multiple pets or professional trainers.
The rechargeable batteries in both the remote transmitter and dog shock collar offer convenience and cost-effectiveness.
The dog shock collar offers a few training modes, including shock, vibration, and tone, allowing you to choose the most suitable option for your dog’s temperament.
With a 500-yard range, it provides ample distance for off-leash training and control in outdoor environments.
The waterproof design of the best shock collar and remote transmitter ensures durability and reliability, even in wet conditions or during water-related activities.
Pros
- These dog training collars are specifically designed to address the needs of stubborn dogs, offering effective training features to tackle a challenging dog’s behavior.
- The package includes an additional shock collar, allowing you to train two dogs at the same time. This is beneficial for owners with multiple dogs or professional trainers working with multiple animals.
- The remote transmitter and the best shock collar feature rechargeable batteries, eliminating the need for disposable batteries. This provides convenience and cost-effectiveness.
- The shock collar offers a variety of training modes, including shock, vibration, and tone. This versatility allows you to choose the most appropriate mode for your dog’s training needs and temperament.
- The shock collar has a range of 500 yards, providing ample distance for off-leash training and control in various outdoor environments.
- The shock collar and remote transmitter are waterproof, making them suitable for training sessions in wet conditions or during water-related activities. This ensures durability and reliability, even in challenging weather conditions.
Cons
- Some individuals may have concerns about using shock as a training method. It’s important to understand and use the shock feature responsibly, ensuring that it is appropriate for your dog’s temperament and training needs.
- Using the various training modes and settings may have a learning curve initially. Familiarizing yourself with the user manual and seeking guidance from professional trainers can help overcome this challenge.
- Each dog has a different sensitivity level, and it’s important to monitor your dog’s response to ensure the chosen stimulation level is appropriate and humane.
PATPET Shock Collars
The PATPET best shock collars are a versatile training tool designed for dogs weighing between 15 and 150 pounds.
With a 3/4-mile range, it allows for effective training and control, even in outdoor settings.
The shock collar offers both shock and vibration stimulation modes, giving you options for tailored correction.
It comes with a remote control for convenient operation and timely feedback during training.
The shock collar and remote are rechargeable and waterproof, ensuring durability and usability in various conditions.
The user-friendly design makes navigating settings and modes for efficient training sessions easy.
Pros
- 1. Shock collars for large dogs weighing between 15 and 150 pounds, accommodating a wide range of breeds.
- 2. With a 3/4-mile range, the shock collar provides ample distance for effective training and control, especially during outdoor activities or off-leash training sessions.
- 3. The shock collar offers both shock and vibration stimulation modes, allowing you to choose the appropriate level of correction based on your dog’s training needs and sensitivities.
- 4. The included remote control enables you to operate and control the collar’s functions, providing convenient and immediate feedback during training sessions.
- 5. The shock collar and remote control are designed to be user-friendly, making it easy to navigate through settings and modes for efficient training sessions.
Cons
- 1. Some users may find it challenging to understand and utilize the various functions and settings of the shock collar, requiring time and patience to familiarize themselves with the device.
- 2. As with any training collar that includes shock stimulation, there is a risk of misuse if not used responsibly or without proper knowledge.
- 3. Dogs have different sensitivities, and it is important to monitor their response to the collar’s stimulation levels to ensure it is appropriate and not overly aversive.
Frequently Asked Questions
What shock collars do police dogs use?
Police dogs, or K9 units, are highly trained working dogs that assist law enforcement agencies in tasks like search and rescue, tracking, and apprehension.
While the best shock collars may be used in their training, the specific brands and models can vary among departments and trainers.
Popular brands/models of best shock collars used by police and working dog units include Garmin/Tri-Tronics, known for their few training modes and GPS tracking capabilities.
Dogtra offers durable best shock collars with various stimulation levels and range options.
SportDOG specializes in training equipment with remote control operation and extended range capabilities.
Do vets recommend shock collars?
The use of the best shock collars in dog training is a subject of debate among veterinarians.
Some support their responsible use in specific circumstances, while others raise concerns about potential risks and negative effects on dogs’ well-being.
Opinions on the best shock collars vary among veterinarians based on their experiences and expertise.
Supporters argue that when used correctly and with professional guidance, shock collars can be effective for training and safety purposes.
Opponents highlight the risks of physical and psychological harm, including stress, fear, and anxiety.
They advocate for positive reinforcement training methods that focus on rewards and building trust with dogs.
Dog owners need to consult a veterinarian and consider the potential benefits and drawbacks before using shock collars as a training tool.
What is the difference between e-collar and shock collar?
The terms “e-collar” and “shock collar” are sometimes used interchangeably, but they have slightly different meanings.
“E-collar” is a broader term that encompasses various electronic collars used for dog training, including those that utilize different types of stimulation such as vibration, sound, and electric shocks.
On the other hand, “shock collar” refers explicitly to electronic collars that deliver electric shock collars as a corrective or aversive stimulus.
These dog collars allow the intensity of the shock to be adjusted, providing a range of levels.
Conclusion
Choosing the best dog shock collars involves careful consideration of safety features, range, durability, training modes, comfort, and the integration of positive reinforcement techniques.
It is crucial to prioritize your dog’s well-being and use the shock collar responsibly, always under the guidance of a professional trainer, if necessary.
Remember, shock collars should be seen as a training aid, not a substitute for consistent and positive training techniques.
With the right shock collars and responsible usage, you can effectively train your shock collars for large dogs while fostering a strong bond built on trust and respect.
The editor’s choice of the best shock collar is the Educator E-Collar Humane Dog Training Collar.
